Gov Business Review Magazine

A featured contribution from Leadership Perspectives: a curated forum reserved for leaders nominated by our subscribers and vetted by the Gov Business Review Advisory Board.

American Bar Association

Eric Storey, Director of Grassroots and Digital Advocacy

Beyond the Action Alert: Building Agency in a Digital-First World

Eric Storey

Eric Storey

Civic Engagement Strategist

The thank-you page may be the most misleading screen in digital advocacy. It tells the participant the action is finished and tells the organization the campaign worked—when neither conclusion is necessarily true. A signature, message, share, or registration is valuable. The real test begins with what happens next.

New research shows how steep that drop-off can be. In a new Harvard Kennedy School working paper, Elizabeth McKenna analyzed a year of participation records covering 38,740 people across 20 civic organizations. 71 percent acted once and did not return during the observation window; among those whose first experience was a mass mobilization, attrition approached 90 percent. The study examines civic-event participation rather than digital action alerts, yet the strategic vulnerability is familiar; scale at the first moment does not guarantee continued participation.

That distinction matters because an action can register support without increasing a participant’s agency, the growing capacity to understand an issue, make meaningful choices, act with others and assume responsibility. Low-friction actions are valuable entry points; for many people, they are how a role in public life begins. The strategic mistake is treating completion as development. Mobilization counts what people do. Agency asks what they become capable of doing.

Behavioral science points to a constellation of influences. Urgency and salience help secure attention. People are more likely to act when an issue connects to their values and identity, the action offers a credible path to influence, and their role feels achievable. Research on self-determination and volunteer retention associates sustained motivation with autonomy, competence, relatedness, communication, organizational support and strong leader relationships. In practical terms, relevance earns attention; efficacy enables action; progress and belonging support another action; autonomy and responsibility cultivate agency.

Those conditions can be designed. In my own work, the strongest engagement has followed a consistent pattern: participants understand the purpose, see where they fit, hear what happened, and gain room to lead. I think of it as the Action-to-Agency Loop: Invite, Equip, Connect, Report Back and Entrust.

Invite answers, “Why should I care, and why now?” Strong invitations establish relevance and moral clarity while respecting choice. They connect an issue to something the audience genuinely values and explain why the moment matters.

Digital tools have made participation easier to trigger. The next challenge is designing experiences that turn a first action into confidence, connection and leadership.

Equip answers, “Can I do this, and can it matter?” Explain the decision, the pathway to influence, and why this action is useful now. Remove unnecessary friction while providing enough context, guidance, and flexibility for participants to act with confidence and authenticity. Low friction should never require low agency.

Connect answers, “Who am I doing this with?” Trusted peers, reciprocal interaction, and visible membership help transform a private act into shared identity. In McKenna’s study, a first event at which most attendees were established members was associated with a 12.8-percentage-point higher probability of return within 90 days, net of event size. The organizational trait most closely associated with that retention capacity was the share of members embedded in teams.

Report Back answers, “Did it matter?” Tell participants what happened, what changed, what did not, and what comes next. A meeting secured, testimony entered, a question asked, or a coalition expanded can make progress visible. Honest feedback and specific recognition show people how their contributions fit into the larger effort.

Entrust answers, “Am I trusted to shape what happens next?” Teach skills, invite judgment, provide discretion, and transfer meaningful responsibility. Participation levels can differ; agency includes the freedom to choose. Those seeking deeper involvement should have paths to contribute, connect others, shape strategy, and lead. Entrust closes the loop when experienced advocates begin inviting, equipping, and connecting others.

The value of the loop is cumulative: each stage prepares people for a deeper and more self-directed role.

Technology should serve this progression. Under Equip, it can translate complex issues into plain language and offer drafting support participants can personalize. Under Connect, it can match people to peers or local teams. Under Report Back, it can deliver timely, tailored outcome updates. Under Entrust, it can support skills coaching and distributed leadership. The guardrails are equally practical: preserve consent, keep human stories authentic, and let human relationships remain human. The best technology gives agency greater reach.

That changes what leaders measure. Action totals still matter, alongside second meaningful actions, reciprocal relationships, skills gained, advocate-initiated activity, participants trusted with responsibility, and leaders who begin developing others.

Look at your last action alert. Ask what the people who acted heard back, who they met and what they were trusted to do next. The answers reveal whether the campaign generated a moment of activity or expanded the human capacity to create change.

The articles from these contributors are based on their personal expertise and viewpoints, and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of their employers or affiliated organizations.